Identity Theft Insurance: What $1 Million Cover Really Pays

Affiliate disclosure: This article contains affiliate links. If you click a link and make a purchase, we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. Our editorial recommendations are never influenced by commissions — read our full disclosure policy.
Identity theft insurance repays the costs of getting your identity back after someone misuses it — time off work, travel, notarising and posting documents, childcare while you deal with it, and lawyers or investigators — and, on some plans, money taken from your accounts that your bank will not return. It does not stop identity theft, and it only pays for eligible losses you report on time and can document. The "$1 million" on a sign-up page is a ceiling, not an expected payout: on LifeLock most of each headline figure is a $1 million bucket for lawyers and experts that LifeLock hires for you, while the part for your own expenses and stolen money is $25,000 on Core, $100,000 on Advanced and $1 million on Total.
This guide reads the policy documents themselves rather than the marketing. Everything below comes from Aura's pricing page and its insurance summary, LifeLock's plan page and the Evidence of Coverage it links for events from 1 September 2026, and the US Consumer Financial Protection Bureau — all read on 12 November 2026. These policies cover US members; outside the US, check what your own bank, card and home insurance already include.
What identity theft insurance pays for
Both big consumer services insure the same kinds of cost. The wording and the limits differ, and the limits are what matter at claim time.
| Cost after identity theft | Aura (summary of benefits) | LifeLock (Evidence of Coverage) |
|---|---|---|
| Notarising, phone calls, postage, replacing IDs | Yes — notarising, long-distance calls, travel and postage; replacement ID cards, licences and passports | Yes — notarisation, phone and fax charges, photocopies and postage for replacing ID documents |
| Lost wages | "Actual lost base wages", within 12 months of discovery, backed by your prior-year tax return | Up to 30 days of lost salary or wages, 8 hours a day, lost within six months of discovery |
| Childcare or elder care | Yes, care "that would have otherwise not been incurred" | Yes, if the carer is a professional who is not your relative |
| Lawyers | Up to $125 an hour | Lawyers and experts retained by LifeLock, up to $1 million on every plan |
| Money stolen from your accounts | Unrecoverable funds, only after you sought reimbursement from your bank | Up to $25,000 (Core), $100,000 (Advanced) or $1 million (Total) |
| Credit reports | Up to six | Not listed as a separate item |
| Cryptocurrency theft | Excluded | Excluded ("Digital Currency") |
| Deductible | No general deductible stated | "Not subject to a deductible" |
Sources: Aura's $1M insurance summary of benefits, underwritten by American Bankers Insurance Company of Florida, an Assurant company; LifeLock's Evidence of Coverage for events on or after 1 September 2026, issued by United Specialty Insurance Company and listed on Norton's legal page.
Why the headline number is not what you would be paid
LifeLock's headline is a sum of buckets. Its plan page advertises "Up to $1.05M Reimbursement for identity theft, with up to $25K for Stolen Funds" on Core, "Up to $1.2M" with up to $100,000 for stolen funds on Advanced, and "Up to $3M" with up to $1 million for stolen funds on Total, and notes "Up to $1 million coverage for Lawyers and Experts included with all plans" (LifeLock plans). The Evidence of Coverage shows how that adds up: on Core, $25,000 a year for your own expenses, $25,000 for stolen funds and $1 million for legal and remediation costs paid to people LifeLock retains. So a Core member who loses $40,000 from a hacked account is insured for $25,000 of it, not $1.05 million.
Aura reports its figure two ways. The pricing page says "every adult member on your plan is backed by a $1,000,000 insurance policy to cover eligible losses and fees due to identity theft", and its plan cards show $1 million, $2 million and $5 million for Individual, Couple and Family (Aura pricing). The summary of benefits states a limit of "$1,000,000 per Single/Family Membership per 12 Month Period", with stolen-funds recovery counted inside that limit, not added to it. If the difference matters to your household, ask Aura in writing which limit applies to your plan before you rely on the higher one.
Is $1 million identity theft insurance meaningful or mostly marketing? Both, honestly. The money most victims spend is in time, travel and paperwork, which rarely approaches any of these limits. The large numbers matter mainly for legal defence — for example, a lawsuit or criminal charge brought against you because of what an impostor did, which LifeLock's policy names explicitly. Neither company publishes an average claim size, so we do not quote one. For comparing plans, the stolen-funds line and the lost-wages terms tell you far more than the headline.
What it will not pay
The exclusions are where claims fail. From the two policy documents:
- Late reporting. LifeLock requires you to notify it within 90 days of discovering the theft, and to report an unauthorised transfer within 12 months of when it happened. Aura's summary asks you to call within 60 days of discovery and file a sworn proof of loss within 60 days, and stolen funds must be reported within 90 days.
- Losses your bank should cover. Aura does not pay stolen funds if you "did not seek reimbursement from the financial institution", and asks for the bank's documentation that the money is non-recoverable.
- Someone you know. LifeLock excludes theft by an immediate family member or anyone living with you — unless you report it to the police and cooperate in prosecution. Aura excludes fraud committed by the member or a family member.
- Your own negligence. LifeLock excludes losses caused by failing to take reasonable care with your personal information or accounts.
- Business and crypto losses. Both exclude losses from business activity, and both exclude stolen cryptocurrency. Aura also excludes losses from "games of chance".
- Knock-on costs. Aura excludes "indirect or consequential loss of any nature"; LifeLock excludes lost profits and other indirect damage.
Your bank comes first
Stolen-funds insurance sits behind the protection the law already gives you. For debit cards and other electronic transfers, the CFPB explains that if you report a lost or stolen card within two business days, the bank "can't hold you responsible for more than the amount of any unauthorized transactions or $50, whichever is less"; after that, you "could be responsible for up to $500". For an unauthorised charge on a statement, you need to tell the bank "within 60 days" of the statement that shows it (CFPB). Reporting fast protects you twice: it limits your liability with the bank and keeps you inside the insurer's deadline.
Scam reimbursement is a separate policy
LifeLock's Advanced and Total plans add "Scam Reimbursement" of $5,000 and $10,000. That is a different group policy, issued by HSB Specialty Insurance Company, with its own terms: the summary of benefits lists a $100 deductible per occurrence, and Norton's plan page says the scam cover is available to US customers "with the exception of residents of New York". Identity theft insurance pays when someone uses your identity; scam cover is aimed at money you were tricked into sending. Read them as two products.
What the two services cost (12 November 2026)
| Aura | LifeLock | |
|---|---|---|
| One adult | $12 a month billed annually, or $15 monthly | Core $124.99 a year; Advanced $199.99; Total $349.99 |
| Expenses and stolen-funds limit | $1,000,000 (see the two wordings above) | $25,000 / $100,000 / $1,000,000 |
| Lawyers and experts | Up to $125 an hour, inside the limit | Up to $1 million on every plan |
| Insurer | American Bankers Insurance Company of Florida (Assurant) | United Specialty Insurance Company; scam cover HSB |
| Guarantee | 14-day free trial; 60-day money-back on annual plans | 60-day money-back on annual plans |
If you want antivirus and identity cover from one company, Norton sells LifeLock and its Norton 360 with LifeLock bundles — visit Norton (affiliate link). The insurance is only one part of either service; our Aura vs LifeLock comparison weighs the monitoring and the restoration help as well, and the LifeLock review and Aura review cover each in full.
How to make a claim that gets paid
1. Report the theft quickly. Call your bank or card issuer first, then your identity protection provider — LifeLock's deadline is 90 days from discovery; Aura's claim line is 1-866-237-5240 and its summary asks for contact within 60 days. 2. File the official reports. A police report, an identity theft report at IdentityTheft.gov, and fraud alerts or freezes with the credit bureaus. Our guide to what to do if your data has been breached lists each step. 3. Keep every receipt and record. Travel, postage, notary fees, childcare invoices, and a note of each day off work. Aura bases lost wages on your prior-year tax return. 4. Get the bank's answer in writing. Both policies treat stolen funds as the money the bank would not return, so you need its final decision. 5. Ask for the full policy. Both summaries say the master policy governs and that a complete copy is available on request.
Do you need to pay for it at all?
Identity theft insurance is not usually sold on its own to consumers — it comes bundled with monitoring and restoration help, so the real question is whether the whole service is worth it to you. Before you decide, check what you may already have: some home or renters policies and some bank or card benefits include identity theft expense cover. We have not surveyed insurers for this guide, so read your own policy documents rather than assuming either way.
If you would rather do the prevention yourself, the free layer — credit freezes, fraud alerts and weekly credit reports — is set out in identity monitoring services explained, and our guide to whether identity theft protection is worth it works through free versus paid. Removing your details from people-search sites is a separate job, covered in data broker removal: free opt-outs vs paid services.
Frequently asked questions
What does identity theft insurance cover?
The costs of restoring your identity: replacing documents, notarising and postage, travel, lost wages for time taken off, childcare or elder care, and legal and expert fees. Some plans also reimburse money stolen from your accounts that your bank will not return, up to a stated limit.
Is $1 million identity theft insurance worth it?
The headline figure is a ceiling, and on LifeLock most of it is for lawyers and experts the company retains. Compare the stolen-funds limit and the lost-wages terms instead: LifeLock's stolen-funds cover is $25,000 on Core, $100,000 on Advanced and $1 million on Total.
What identity theft expenses does Aura's insurance cover compared with LifeLock?
Both cover document replacement, travel, lost wages, childcare and legal costs. Aura's summary caps lawyers at $125 an hour and bases lost wages on your prior-year tax return; LifeLock pays lawyers and experts it retains up to $1 million and caps lost income at 30 days. Stolen-funds limits differ by LifeLock plan; Aura counts stolen funds inside its $1,000,000 limit.
Does identity theft insurance cover stolen money?
Sometimes, and only after your bank has refused. Aura requires that you sought reimbursement from the financial institution, and LifeLock's stolen-funds cover depends on your plan. Stolen cryptocurrency is excluded by both.
Is there a deductible on identity theft insurance?
LifeLock's identity theft policy states it is "not subject to a deductible"; its separate scam reimbursement has a $100 deductible per occurrence. Aura's summary of benefits does not state a general deductible.
Covered in this guide
Written by Thomas Lovas Lokoy, Founder & Editor — researched and drafted with AI assistance from published sources; edited and published by NorwegianSpark SA · Editorial policy · Disclosure · Last updated: 12 November 2026




